THE TRUE HOME OF THE SUPERSIZED PIE

Goodfella’s Pizza Italian Restaurant is a family owned and operated restaurant that takes pride in it’s service and quality. We ensure that every pizza and meal served is handmade exactly to our specifications so we can deliver on our promise of quality.

ORDER ONLINE

GOOD FOOD

Hand-made Artisan Craft Specialty Pizzas with a mix of Italian-American meals. Children’s menu available.

FULL MENU

GOOD DRINKS

Full service bar with cocktails, wine & beer selection, cordials, and drink specials.

DRINK SPECIALS

GOOD TIMES

Weekly live events, full catering & conference room with bar, projector, sound system, and giant TV.

BISTRO ROOM
The Bistro Party Room

Come and Experience

THE BISTRO

Offering buffet, family style, and sit-down lunches and dinners with a wine, beer, and spirits bar, large screen TV, and projector makes it the perfect location to host local businesses and large groups for parties, other activities and events.

  • Banquet Hall Available

Parties, Banquets, Communions & Graduations Wedding & Bridal Showers, Meetings, & Large Gatherings

BOOK EVENT
  • Weekly Events and Entertainment

Live music events, trivia, concerts, movie premiers, karaoke, holiday events as well as paint & sips, family friendly activities and so much more.

Have an idea for an event or wish to host an upcoming free or admission public event at The Bistro, let us know. There’s always GOOD FOOD, GOOD DRINKS, and GOOD TIMES at
The Bistro Party Room!

UPCOMING EVENTS

"PIZZA TO DIE FOR"

Freddy G
Freddy G
★★★★★
Great people, service, and the food are made to perfection 👌 all the way from Lawrence Ma. I'm looking forward to trying new dishes in the future.
Barbara J
Barbara J
★★★★★
So good! The personal pizzas will easily feed 2 and were delish. Fresh veggies added a perfect crunch to the veggie pizza. Service was quick and friendly. Restrooms were clean. Definitely found our new lunch spot when we trek from New England to Southern PA!
Amanita V
Amanita V
★★★★★
Food was very good servers were very friendly. I had the eggplant parmesan dinner and my companion had the chicken Caesar. Both were very good. We went again recently and they have a new room added, where they do trivia night and have live bands. It looks like it would be lots of fun for a night out!
Keller Williams
Keller Williams
★★★★★
Goodfellas Pizza Italian Restaurant in Matamoras, PA, delivers a delicious experience reminiscent of its cinematic namesake. With an extensive menu featuring a variety of mouthwatering Italian dishes and, of course, pizzas, the restaurant offers a genuine taste of Italy.
Bryan H
Bryan H
★★★★★
The Veal Parm was authentic and delicious. Prices were reasonable. Will definitely have that again and look forward to trying the pizza. Staff was friendly and attentive.
Lauren G
Lauren G
★★★★★
Lovely Italian pizza place that has a good share of delicious entrees as well. Great drinks. Love their chicken parm and their Sicilian pizza.
Leave a Review

BOOK YOUR EVENT AT

THE BISTRO

All joking aside, we truly appreciate you considering Goodfella's Pizza and The BISTRO PARTY ROOM! We look forward to serving you and your guests. A Goodfella's representative will be in contact with you shortly to discuss the details of your event.

Contact Goodfella's

EMAIL: owners@goodfellaspizzapa.com

PHONE: 570-491-8191

ADDRESS: 111 Hulst Drive, Matamoras, PA 18336

HOURS:
Sun – Thurs • 11am – 9pm
Fri – Sat • 11am – 10pm

LOOKING FOR SOMETHING

LETS BE SOCIAL

Follow us on social media for frequent updates on new menu items, specials, and live events.

Facebook-f Instagram Tripadvisor Google

Copyright 2025 Goodfella’s Pizza Italian Restaurant  •  All Rights Reserved  •  Privacy Policy